Isn't it supposed to be "whose job is" rather than "whose job it is"? I'm not sure, but I think it's grammatically incorrect.

Native speaker’s answer

Rebecca

Both of them are correct and both are commonly used. If you switch the relative clause "whose job it is" into a main clause it could read as: "It is [someone's] job." But since the determiner "whose" is used, it becomes "whose job it is." There is also a slight difference in nuances. "Whose job is" could make it sound like that it's that person's <only> job. Whereas "whose job it is" can refer to just one of their jobs and not all of them. But you can also use them interchangeably if referring to one job. Ex: We have an intern whose job it is to print documents for us. => This is only one of the intern's tasks. Ex: We have an intern whose job is to print documents. => This makes it sound like this is their only job.

How do native speakers use this expression?

Share this post

Popular Q&As

12/31

1
Can I use the phrase "annually" instead of "every year"?
Yes, I believe you can use "annually" instead of "every year" here. However, you would have to change the sentence slightly for the sentence to make sense. It would have to be "Thousands of Canadians lose a limb annually." Ex: We go on a camping trip every year. = We go on an annual camping trip. Ex: The convention takes place in Los Angeles every year. = The convention takes place annually in Los Angeles.

2
What is the nuance of "come on" in this case?
"Come on" here is used to express disbelief or show that you don't think someone is being serious about something. It is similar to saying "yeah, right" in a sarcastic way. It can also be used in this way to express annoyance. It is usually said in a slow, sarcastic tone. Ex: Come on, you can't be serious, you're just being dramatic. Ex: Oh come on, it's not that bad, just try it!

3
What is the difference between "cover one's eyes" and "close one's eyes"?
Closing one's eyes refers to the action of closing your eyelids, whereas to cover one's eyes means to use something (like a hand) to block out vision or sunlight. As shown in the video, the speaker has covered his eye with his hand to prevent himself from accidentally seeing something, which is a different action than simply closing his eyes. Ex: Close your eyes and go to sleep. Ex: He covered his eyes with his hands.

4
What does "got it" mean here?
Good question! You'll hear this expression in the sports context a lot. It's an exclamation used when a play has been successful. For example, when a ball has been caught. You might also hear "got him/her," which expresses that a player on the opposing team has been stopped or caught. In any case, it's used to express a successful play. Ex: Got it! He got the ball! Ex: Got him! Let's take the others down too.

5
It seems like the sentence still makes sense without the word "necessary." If I say "you're less motivated to do the actual hard work" instead of "you're less motivated to do the actual hard work necessary", what gets different?
You are correct. The sentence does make sense without the word "necessary." Both sentences have the same meaning. Having "necessary" makes the sentence a little more formal. Since this gentleman is giving a speech to a larger crowd, he may have wanted to sound more formal. Regardless, you would be fine using this sentence with or without "necessary."

Complete the expression with a quiz!