student asking question

Can I say "the girl" instead of "a girl" here?

teacher

Native speaker’s answer

Rebecca

The speaker has used "a" to specify a girl in general. If a girl had been mentioned previously, it would then be appropriate to use "the" as it would be referring to a specific person. However, the speaker only wishes to share that there is a girl in Luke's bed, and he does not know her identity at this point nor has he mentioned a girl previously in conversation with his wife. Ex: There's a cat lying on my porch. I have no idea who its owner is. Ex: There's the cat we saw earlier.

Popular Q&As

04/16

Complete the expression with a quiz!