Can I replace "middle-class" with "working class"?

Native speaker’s answer

Rebecca

While "middle-class" and "working class" are similar, they both have slightly different meanings, and it would change the meaning of the sentence if you were to switch them. "Middle-class" here refers to people who fall between the category of making an annual income that is above the poverty line to very high above the poverty line. Here, they even clarify and say they are "upper middle-class", which means they have a high annual income of something close to $100,000 U.S. Dollars per year. "Working class" is usually the class just below the middle class, although sometimes people classify the "working class" to fall at the bottom of the "middle class". "Working-class" mostly refers to people who work in labor-intensive, blue-collar jobs, and unlike the "middle-class", this expression does not clearly specify income.

How do native speakers use this expression?

Share this post

Popular Q&As

04/19

1
Is there any words that can be used instead of "particular"?
Here particular is being used as an adjective referring to a specific thing rather than others. Therefore some good synonyms in this particular context would be "special", "specific" or "certain".

2
What's the difference between "refugee" and "exodus"?
A “refugee” is any person fleeing their home (or country) due to reasons of war, religion, politics, the economy, or any other forms of persecution. An “exodus” is not a person but a mass departure or migration, which can include people. Thus, refugees may be part of an exodus, but an exodus is not always caused by refugees. Ex: The number of refugees displaced by environmental change is growing. Ex: Every year, there is a mass exodus of retirees to sunny vacation spots in the South.

3
How will it be different if I use the word "condition" instead of "demand" here?
If you used "condition," it would be acceptable within this context! However, there is a slight difference in nuance. A "condition" implies a compromise that benefits both parties, even if there are "conditions". A "demand" is the thing that this person really wants. For him, it's the demand or nothing. It's not a compromise. Ex: I'll help you with one condition. You have to buy us ice cream afterwards. Ex: She's demanding to see you. Otherwise, she won't leave.

4
Why does he suddenly say "breathe it in"? What does "it" refer here?
Maui has made up a narcissistic song about himself. When he says, "yes, it's really me, Maui, breathe it in", "breathe it in" is meant in a similar way to "let it sink in.", which means to 'understand or accept'. "It" doesn't really refer to anything here, the main purpose of this phrase is to exaggerate Maui's greatness and make Moana feel amazement at being in his presence. Unlike in this video, when "breathe it in" is used in the conventional sense, it is used to tell someone to breathe in the air or smells around them. Ex: I love the smell of freshly baked cookies. Breathe it in! Ex: The air is so fresh by the ocean. Breathe in that air!

5
Is "quite" different from "very"? If I say "very considerable", does the meaning get changed?
"Quite" is similar to "fairly," "rather," "somewhat," and "relatively." This means that the degree is significant enough to take into consideration, but not to the point of "very," which is stronger. Ex. This shirt is quite nice. (This shirt is rather nice.) Ex: Work has been quite smooth this week.

Complete the expression with a quiz!