What does “Carry Coals To Newcastle” mean?
"Carry Coals To Newcastle" means to do something unnecessary or redundant.
What context can I use the in?
Example
Bringing sand to the beach is like carrying coals to Newcastle.
Example
Telling her how to do her job is like carrying coals to Newcastle.
Example
Suggesting a new restaurant to a food critic is like carrying coals to Newcastle
Is “Carry Coals To Newcastle” an expression, an idiom, or a proverb?
“Carry Coals To Newcastle” is a proverb. A proverb is a short saying that teaches us something important or gives us advice. Unlike an idiom, it’s easy to understand even if it uses figurative language.
How would I use “Carry Coals To Newcastle” effectively in context?
You can use "Carry Coals To Newcastle" to describe doing something that is unnecessary or redundant. It emphasizes the futility of the action. For example, if someone is offering to help you with a task that you have already completed, you might say, 'Thanks, but it's like carrying coals to Newcastle. I've already finished it.'
- 1Gift Giving
Giving her a book on a topic she's an expert in is like carrying coals to Newcastle. She probably already has a library full of books on that subject.
- 2Advice
Telling a professional chef how to cook is like carrying coals to Newcastle. They already have extensive knowledge and experience in the kitchen.
- 3Recommendations
Suggesting a new fashion trend to a fashionista is like carrying coals to Newcastle. They are already up-to-date with the latest trends.
Similar phrases to “Carry Coals To Newcastle”:
Good things to know:
Where does the phrase “Carry Coals To Newcastle” come from?
The origin of the phrase "Carry Coals To Newcastle" dates back to the 17th century. Newcastle, a city in England, was known for its coal mining industry. It was one of the largest coal exporters in the world at that time. Therefore, bringing coal to Newcastle would be completely unnecessary and redundant, as the city already had an abundance of it.
Is “Carry Coals To Newcastle” common in everyday conversation?
Yes, "Carry Coals To Newcastle" is a well-known idiom in everyday conversation. While it may not be used as frequently as some other idioms, it is still commonly understood and used to convey the idea of doing something unnecessary or redundant.
What tone does “Carry Coals To Newcastle” have?
"Carry Coals To Newcastle" conveys a tone of futility and redundancy. It is often used humorously or sarcastically to highlight the pointlessness of an action or suggestion.
Can “Carry Coals To Newcastle” be used in informal and formal settings?
Yes, "Carry Coals To Newcastle" can be used in both informal and formal settings. It is a versatile expression that conveys the idea of doing something unnecessary. You can use it in everyday conversations with friends, family, and colleagues, as well as in more formal situations such as presentations, meetings, or professional correspondence.
Can it be used by itself, or is it usually part of a sentence?
It's commonly used as part of a sentence to convey its full meaning. For example, 'Bringing more food to the potluck is like carrying coals to Newcastle.' However, in informal conversations, people might understand the phrase even if used alone, like saying 'Carrying coals to Newcastle!' to imply the futility of a certain action.
