Is the word "that" necessary after "Either"? Is it grammatically incorrect or does it change the meaning if I omit "that" here?

Native speaker’s answer
Rebecca
Yes, "that" is needed after "either." The sentence would be considered incomplete if you removed "that" from this sentence. The phrase "either that" indicates only two choices are available: Genie is getting bigger, or Aladdin is smaller than his previous master. Removing "that" takes away the understanding of the two choices available. "Either that" means "this or that." Ex: I want a raise. Either that or I'm quitting! Ex: We are taking her with us. Either that or you can stay home. "Either" does not always need to be followed by "that." It is usually needed when the two choices are in different sentences. Ex: You can either stay with your dad this weekend or come on vacation with me. Ex: He will either come in late or not show up.